Compiled comments on first consultation

Following revision of the standard setting procedure agreed to by IPPC contracting parties at CPM-11 (2016) the period known as member consultation has now been renamed as the 'first consultation'.

The Secretariat will post all comments from the first consultation after the close of the commenting period below.

The steward(s) or relevant TP reviews the comments, prepares responses to the comments and revises the draft ISPM and submits them to the Secretariat. These are posted for the SC.

The SC reviews the comments submitted from the first consultation, the Steward(s)' responses to the comments and the revised ISPM. The SC decides whether to recommend the draft ISPM to the CPM, or to put it on hold, return it to the Steward(s) or to an expert drafting group (EDG), or submit it for another round of consultation.

The IPPC Secretariat requests members to review the compiled comments and contact the Secretariat if their comments have not been recorded correctly.

The Secretariat posts the draft ISPM on the IPP in the languages of the organization as soon as possible and at least 6 weeks prior to the opening of the CPM meeting.

2015-04-19 last updated. For queries or comments regarding the contents of this page, please contact him at paul.howard@fao.org
Title Files Publication date
2009 Member comments on draft Diagnostic protocol for Thrips palmi Rev.1 (November 19, 2009) En 19 Nov 2009
2009 Member Comments on Draft Amendment to Glossary (Rev. 2 November 19, 2009) En 19 Nov 2009
2009 Member Comments on Draft Cold Treatments Rev.1 (November 19, 2009) En 19 Nov 2009
2010 Member Consultation Compiled Comments for Draft ISPM Systems Approaches for Pest Risk Management of Fruit Flies (Tephritidae) En 21 Feb 2011
2010 Member Consultation Compiled Comments for Draft ISPM Annex to ISPM 27: 2010 Plum Pox Virus En 17 Dec 2010
2010 Member Consultation Compiled Comments for Draft ISPM Annex to ISPM 28: 2009 Irradiation Treatment for Ceratitis capitata En 29 Nov 2010
2010 Member Consultation Compiled Comments for Draft ISPM Appendix to ISPM 15: 2009 Submission of New Treatments for Inclusion in ISPM 15: REVISED En 17 Dec 2010
2010 Member Consultation Compiled Comments for Draft ISPM Integrated Measures Approach for Plants for Planting in International Trade En 20 Dec 2010
2011 Compiled Comments REVISED: Draft amendments to ISPM 5. Glossary of phytosanitary terms (1994-001) En 13 Oct 2011
2011 Compiled Comments: Draft revision to Supplement no. 1. Guidelines on the interpretation and application of the concept of official control for regulated pests (Not widely distributed) of ISPM 5. Glossary of phytosanitary terms (2005-008) En 10 Oct 2011
2011 Compiled Comments REVISED: Draft annex 4 to ISPM 11:2004. Pest risk analysis for plants as quarantine pest and consequential changes in core text of ISPM 11:2004 (2005-001) En 13 Oct 2011
2011 Compiled Comments: Draft revision to Annex 1 of ISPM 15:2009. Approved treatments associated with wood packaging material (2006-011) En 10 Oct 2011
2011 Compiled Comments REVISED: Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006: Trogoderma granarium (2004-006) En 13 Oct 2011
2011 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007. Vapour heat treatment of Cucumis melo var. reticulatus for Bactrocera cucurbitae (2006-110) En 10 Oct 2011
2011 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007. Heat treatment of wood packaging material using dielectric heat (2007-114) En 10 Oct 2011
2012 Compiled comments - Electronic certification, Appendix to ISPM 12:2011 (2006-003) En 29 Oct 2012
2012 Compiled comments - Fruit fly quarantine areas (2009-007) En 29 Oct 2012
2012 Compiled comments - Draft DP: Tilletia indica Mitra (2004-014) En 29 Oct 2012
2012 Compiled comments - Guignardia citricarpa Kiely on fruit (2004-023) En 06 Nov 2012
2012 Compiled comments - Fruit fly host status (2006-031) En 29 Oct 2012
2013 Compiled comments - Draft Amendments to ISPM 5: Glossary of Phytosanitary terms (1994-001) En 03 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006 – Potato spindle tuber viroid (2006-022) En 03 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Draft ISPM - Minimizing pest movement by sea containers (2008-001) En 04 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007: Irradiation (2012-011) En 04 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Movement of growing media in association with plants for planting in international trade (2005-004) En 04 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Phytosanitary Procedures for Fruit Fly (Tephritidae) Management (2005-010) En 04 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006 – Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri (2004-011) En 04 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Management of pest risks associated with international movement of wood (2006-029) En 04 Dec 2013
2013 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007: Irradiation (2012-011) - SC November 2014 responses to member comments En 26 Nov 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Amendments to ISPM 5: Glossary of phytosanitary terms (1994-001) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006 - Erwinia amylovora (Burrill) (2004-009) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006 - Genus Anastrepha (2004-015) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006 - Ditylenchus dipsaci and Ditylenchus destructor (2004-017) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006 - Phytoplasmas (2004-018) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft ISPM on International movement of seeds (2009-003) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007 - High temperature forced air treatment for Bactrocera melanotus and B. xanthodes (Diptera: Tephritidae) on Carica papaya (2009-105) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007 - Vapour heat treatment for Bactrocera dorsalis on Carica papaya var. Solo (2009-109) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007 - Cold treatment for Ceratitis capitata on Citrus clementina var. Clemenules (2010-102) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007 - Cold treatment for Ceratitis capitata on Citrus sinensis var. Navel and Valencia (2010-103) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007 - Vapour heat treatment for Ceratitis capitata on Mangifera indica (2010-106) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 28:2007 - Irradiation for Ostrinia nubilalis (2012-009) En 02 Dec 2014
2014 Compiled comments - Draft ISPM on International movement of used vehicles, machinery and equipment (2006-004) En 02 Dec 2014
2013 Compiled comments - Draft Annex to ISPM 27:2006 – Potato spindle tuber viroid (2006-022)-SC November 2014 responses to member comments En 11 Dec 2014
2004 A-C_country comments En 10 Dec 2004
2004 D-J_country comments En 10 Dec 2004
2004 K-M_country comments En 10 Dec 2004
2004 N-R_country comments En 10 Dec 2004
2004 S-Z_country comments En 10 Dec 2004
Comments A-C (Antigua to China) En 01 Feb 2006
Comments C (Colombia to Cosave) En 01 Feb 2006
Comments C-K (Costa Rica to Kenya) En 01 Feb 2006
Comments L-M (Laos to Mauritius) En 01 Feb 2006
Comments M-S (Mexico to Samoa) En 01 Feb 2006
Comments S-Z (Seychelles to Yemen) En 01 Feb 2006
Comments - fast-track 2005 En 01 Feb 2006
2007 Comments A-C (Argentina to COSAVE) En 01 Jan 2007
2007 Comments C-H (Costa Rica to Honduras) En 01 Jan 2007
2007 Comments I-M (India to Mauritius) En 01 Jan 2007
2007 Comments M-P (Mozambique to Paraguay) En 01 Jan 2007
2007 Comments P-Z (Peru to Vietnam) En 01 Jan 2007
2008 Member comments on draft ISPMs: Structure and operation of post-entry quarantine facilities En 23 Oct 2008
2008 Member comments on draft ISPMs: Categorization of commodities according to their phytosanitary risk En 23 Oct 2008
2008 Member comments on draft ISPMs: Amendments to ISPM No. 5 (Glossary of phytosanitary terms) En 23 Oct 2008
2008 Member comments on draft ISPMs: Terminology of the Convention on Biological Diversity in relation to the Glossary of phytosanitary terms En 23 Oct 2008
2008 Member comments on draft ISPMs: Regulating wood packaging material in international trade (revision of ISPM No. 15) En 29 Oct 2008
2009 Member Comments on Draft ISPMS: Fruit FlyTrapping En 10 Feb 2009
2009 Member Comments on Draft ISPMs: Pest Free Potato Micropropagative Material and Minitubers for International Trade En 10 Feb 2009
2009 Member comments on Draft revision of ISPM No. 7 En 23 Oct 2009
2009 Member comments on Draft revision of ISPM No. 12 Rev. 1 (November 19, 2009) En 19 Nov 2009
2014 Compiled comments with SC Responses: Draft Annex to ISPM 27 - Genus Anastrepha (2004-015) En 30 Jun 2015
2009 Member comments on Draft ISPM Post Entry Quarantine Rev. 1 (November 19, 2009) En 19 Nov 2009
2014 Compiled comments with SC Responses: Draft Annex to ISPM 27- Ditylenchus dipsaci and Ditylenchus destructor (2004-017) En 30 Jun 2015
2014 Compiled comments with SC Responses: Draft Annex to ISPM 27-Phytoplasmas (2004-018) En 30 Jun 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 27– Bursaphelenchus xylophilus (2004-016) En 01 Jul 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 27–Tomato spotted wilt virus, Impatiens necrotic spot virus and Watermelon silver mottle virus (2004-019) En 01 Jul 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 27– Citrus tristeza virus (2004-021) En 01 Jul 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 27–Xiphinema americanum sensu lato (2004-025) En 01 Jul 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 27– Genus Liriomyza (2006-017) En 01 Jul 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft ANNEX TO ISPM 27 – XANTHOMONAS FRAGARIAE (2004-012) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft Appendix to ISPM 20 – Arrangements for verification of compliance of consignments by the importing country in the exporting country (2005-003) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft revisions to ISPM 15 (Regulation of wood packaging material in international trade) (2006-010A and B) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: DRAFT ANNEX to ISPM 27 – Sorghum halepense (2006-027) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: DRAFT ANNEX TO ISPM 27 – APHELENCHOIDES BESSEYI, A. FRAGARIAE AND A. RITZEMABOSI (2006-025) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft sulphuryl fluoride fumigation of insects in debarked wood (2007-101A) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft sulphuryl fluoride fumigation of nematodes and insects in debarked wood (2007-101B) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft Heat treatment of wood using dielectric heating (2007-114) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled Comments: Draft vapour heat treatment for bactrocera tryoni on mangifera indica (2010-107) En 01 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27- Bursaphelenchus xylophilus (2004-016) En 15 Dec 2015
2014 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 28-Ostrinia nubilalis (2012-109) En 20 Jan 2016
2015 Compiled comments with SC responses to formal objection: Draft annex to ISPM 27-Phytoplasmas (2004-018) En 15 Dec 2015
2015 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27 Xiphinema americanum (2004-025) En 15 Dec 2015
2014 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft Annex to ISPM 28 - Vapour heat treatment for Bactrocera melanotus and B. xanthodes on Carica papaya (2009-105) En 20 Jan 2016
2015 Compiled Comments: 2006-010A and B: Draft revisions to ISPM 15 (Regulation of wood packaging material in international trade) En
2016 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27 Erwinia amylovora (2004-009) En 30 Jun 2016
2016 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27 Genus Liriomyza (2006-017) En 30 Jun 2016
2016 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27 Tomato spotted wilt virus (TSWV), Impatiens necrotic spot virus (INSV) and Watermelon silver mottle virus(WSMoV) (2004-019) En 30 Jun 2016
2016 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27 Citrus tristeza virus (2004-021) En 30 Jun 2016
2016 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27 Aphelenchoides besseyi, A. ritzemabosi and A. fragariae (2006-025) En 30 Jun 2016
2016 Compiled comments with SC responses: Draft annex to ISPM 27 Xanthomonas fragariae (2004-012) En 30 Jun 2016
2016 Compiled Comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 27- Anguina spp. 2013-003 En 01 Jul 2016
2016 Compiled comments: Draft Annex to ISPM 27- Dendroctonus ponderosae 2006-019 En 01 Jul 2016

Download multiple files